• James Anderson

Appeal court upholds oath to Queen in citizenship case

Updated: Apr 21


The Ontario Court of Appeal has recently weighed in on the ongoing Citizenship Oath to the Queen saga. In an unanimous decision the Court has ruled that swearing the Oath to the Queen does not violate the applicants' Charter Rights, namely their Freedom of Express, their Freedom of Conscience or Religion, and their Equality Rights (e.g., national origin).

The Applicants had misunderstood the meaning of the oath to the Queen as an individual. The Court quoted the words of Justice Laskin that viewing “Her Majesty the Queen” as an individual was an anachronism and held that the reference to the Queen in the oath was a reference to our form of government (para 127).

The case has drawn a lot of media attention, and I have included some links to those articles:

  • http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/appeal-court-upholds-oath-to-queen-in-citizenship-case/article20032155/

  • http://www.ctvnews.ca/canada/oath-to-the-queen-upheld-by-ontario-court-in-citizenship-challenge-1.1958104

  • http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/oath-to-the-queen-upheld-by-ontario-court-of-appeal-1.2735431

Here is the link to the Ontario Court of Appeal decision in McAteer v. Canada (Attorney General) 2014 ONCA 578.

James Anderson

#citizenship #immigration

James Anderson © 2014 | Divorce Lawyer | Wills Lawyer | Trial Lawyer | Immigration Lawyer | Notary Public

162 Metcalfe Street, Suite 300, Ottawa, ON, K2P 1P2  Tel: 613-261-9024   Fax: 613-916-6355   email:  james@andersonlawyers.ca

Please read the Firm's TERMS OF USE page for more information.